Simultaneously, the recent popularity of AI tools, such as ChatGPT, has prompted interest in the use of such technology in the classroom; in 2023, more than half of U.S. state agencies agreed that they are seeing increased interest in guidance or policy around the use of AI in the classroom compared to the previous year. Consequently, the United States has been experiencing a surge in demand for digital learning. Projections show that the global e-learning market is forecast to reach almost 400 billion U.S. dollars by 2026 and the United States is one of the top countries in terms of revenue generated from online learning platforms.
Edtech in K-12 education
According to a survey conducted during the 2022-23 school year, the most accessed edtech by K-12 students and teachers in the U.S. was supplemental platforms, such as online activities, games, and research generally used to aid individual learning. Results also revealed that the top supplemental platform used during the 2022-23 school year was Nearpod, while Google classroom and Quizlet were ranked as the top learning management system and the top study tool, respectively. In that same year, a survey found more than half of K-12 teachers to believe that the biggest impact of edtech for students was on self-paced learning, extension and enrichment, and learning tools for accessibility, suggesting that edtech may help to enable learning for a diverse range of students. In addition, 68 percent of K-12 teachers highlighted that they would like more edtech to support students who may require individualized education plans to meet their learning needs, with over 30 percent also agreeing that there could be more edtech resources to promote student mental health and support students with physical disabilities.
However, according to a survey conducted during the 2021-22 school year, K-12 teachers found challenges with incorporating digital instructional materials into the classroom, including teaching skills that can't be learned via technology and not receiving enough guidance from the school. The use of technology in K-12 education has also prompted cybersecurity and privacy concerns that children may face greater risks by using the Internet and providing their data online. In addition, the increasing popularity of AI tools has caused concern for K-12 teachers who fear that such technology will ultimately make their jobs more difficult in three years’ time, particularly as most of them had not been given any instructions on how AI tools should be used within the classroom. Data from college campuses paint a similar picture; although 65 percent of undergraduate students in 2023 agreed that AI will improve how students learn, 85 percent said they would feel more comfortable using AI tools if they were developed and vetted by trusted academic sources.
Is online college worth the cost?
While over half of surveyed college students in 2023 believed that digital learning has made access to education beyond high school better for all students, supporting the theory that edtech helps to promote learning for a diverse range of students, the data suggests that they remain unconvinced of the quality of online education compared to traditional on-campus programs. Although over 30 percent agreed that online programs have improved geographic convenience and flexibility of academic offerings, a similar share said that fully online programs have worsened the quality of instruction and worsened students’ communication and collaboration skills. In addition, a 2022 survey found 43 percent of college students to believe that the quality of online instruction was worse than that of in-person instruction.
Studies have also shown that the majority of college students in the U.S. rarely preferred coursework, such as group projects, giving a presentation, and class discussions, to be conducted online rather than in person and in 2023, only seven percent of U.S. college students strongly agreed that it was worthwhile for borrowers to take out loans for a higher education that is predominantly online, a decrease from 12 percent in 2021. However, the most common reason for online college selection among U.S. students in 2023 was the affordability of the program, suggesting that it may not always be necessary to take out student loans for some online programs. In that same year, 42 percent of online college students said that the reason they chose online degree programs was because existing commitments, such as work and family, did not allow for attendance in campus-based courses. Consequently, online programs may provide a more flexible and affordable option for students who may have other commitments outside of school.